G2Research Hub
Skip to content
Executive summary

Will cart abandonment disappear because of agentic commerce?

34%

Agent Walk-Aways Leave No Signal

When an agent looks at a business and buys elsewhere, a third of merchants would see no signal at all. Cart abandonment has a successor that most merchants can't yet see. (Base: 157 online sellers.)

13%

Agent Order Errors Have Started

Where agents already buy, errors have started: about one merchant in eight has handled a wrong product, size or price from an agent order. (Base: 47 merchants that let agents buy.)

33%

Reputation Beats Product Data

Merchants expect reputation and reviews to win over agents (33%), well ahead of the structured product data agents rely on (13%). (Base: 165 online sellers.)

51%

Complaints Are the First Warning

Half expect a customer complaint to be the first sign an agent journey went wrong, and no single team owns that journey. (Base: 166 online sellers.)

Portrait of Bob Legters, Chief Product Officer, Paysafe

“Agentic commerce is moving from idea to reality, and consumers will decide how far it goes. Shoppers are increasingly ready to let agents search and compare on their behalf, with many welcoming the convenience while still wanting the final say. This research shows merchants expect the checkout to endure as a clear moment of customer approval, and that experience has to be fast, simple and secure because trust is what makes agentic commerce work. As agents begin to shop, our focus is on giving consumers the confidence to pay how they want, with the control they expect.”

Bob Legters, Chief Product Officer, Paysafe
Chapter 01

Merchants Can't See Most of the AI Agents Already Buying From Them

Half of online sellers (49%) can't tell AI agent traffic or purchases apart from human ones. Merchants that already let AI agents buy are no better off: of the 48 that do (29% of online sellers), only 12% can reliably tell an agent's order from a human's.

Diagram: The checkout journey merchants can see, and the one they can't. Today, a person shops in five steps: lands on the site, browses and compares, adds to cart, fills in checkout, pays and gets confirmation; every step leaves a signal such as page views, dwell time and abandoned carts. Next, an AI agent shops: the shopper asks an AI assistant, the agent reads and compares sites, the agent picks a merchant or walks away, the shopper approves the purchase, and the order arrives. The two middle steps are run by the agent, and many merchants get little or no signal from them.
Finding 1.1

How Many Online Retailers Can Tell AI Agent Traffic From Human Traffic?

Can your analytics tell AI agent traffic or purchases from human ones?
49%
Can't tell agents apart
Can't tell agents apart
49%
Partly, through bot or referral signals
25%
Reliably, with custom tracking
12%
Other answers
14%
Bases include respondents who answered the question.
Data for: Can your analytics tell AI agent traffic or purchases from human ones?
LabelValueSourceBase
Can't tell agents apart49%All online sellers, base: 156. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Partly, through bot or referral signals25%All online sellers, base: 156. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Reliably, with custom tracking12%All online sellers, base: 156. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Other answers14%All online sellers, base: 156. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—

Bases include respondents who answered the question.

“We don't know what we don't know. So we don't know if there are agents that behave exactly as humans.”

Head of product, media publisher
when asked about telling AI agents apart from human shoppers
Listen

“I would not understand that directly. I'm not measuring for whether the request is coming through an AI agent or a human. There is no way for me to distinguish between the two. At least I am not aware of a way. The customer would need to come in directly and actually complain formally and explain how they got to the product page.”

Owner, candle and fragrance brand
when asked about telling AI agents apart from human shoppers
Finding 1.2

No Problems Yet⁠ Mostly Means Can't See Yet

84%

of online sellers say no agent purchase has ever gone wrong for them

Strategic Implication
Chapter 02

When an AI Agent Walks Away, Most Merchants Can't Tell

Cart abandonment has a successor: agent abandonment. If an agent looked at their business and chose a competitor, a third of online sellers (34%) say they would see nothing at all, and another 27% would see only an ordinary bounce that looks like a human leaving.

Finding 2.1

What Would Merchants See If an AI Agent Decided Not to Buy From Them?

41%

of companies with up to 250 employees would see nothing at all

If an AI agent decided not to buy from or recommend you, what would you see?
34%
Nothing at all
Nothing at all
34%
An ordinary bounce or abandoned session
27%
Indirect signs, such as traffic shifts, AI visibility or reviews
16%
Other answers
23%
Bases include respondents who answered the question.
Data for: If an AI agent decided not to buy from or recommend you, what would you see?
LabelValueSourceBase
Nothing at all34%Base: 157 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
An ordinary bounce or abandoned session27%Base: 157 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Indirect signs, such as traffic shifts, AI visibility or reviews16%Base: 157 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Other answers23%Base: 157 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—

Bases include respondents who answered the question.

“I don't think we would be able to see and say, hey, an AI agent declined to proceed with you and why. We would just consider that an abandonment, and we wouldn't know whether it was a human or an AI agent.”

Travel company
when asked about AI agents choosing a competitor
Finding 2.2

If More Sales Came Through AI Agents, What Would You Want to Measure That You Can't Today?

Strategic Implication
If more sales came through AI agents, what would you want to measure that you can't today?
28%
Where agent traffic comes from and what the shopper asked
Where agent traffic comes from and what the shopper asked
28%
Why an agent dropped them or chose a competitor
25%
Agent conversion rate and purchase success
12%
Lifetime value and satisfaction of agent customers
5%
Other answers
30%
Bases include respondents who answered the question.
Data for: If more sales came through AI agents, what would you want to measure that you can't today?
LabelValueSourceBase
Where agent traffic comes from and what the shopper asked28%Base: 165 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Why an agent dropped them or chose a competitor25%Base: 165 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Agent conversion rate and purchase success12%Base: 165 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Lifetime value and satisfaction of agent customers5%Base: 165 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Other answers30%Base: 165 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—

Bases include respondents who answered the question.

Chapter 03

Merchants' Own Fraud and Bot Checks Are the Agent Blocker They Aren't Counting

A third of online sellers named a bot check, CAPTCHA, fraud rule or authentication step they expect would stop an agent mid-purchase. Yet when we asked why an agent might pass them over, almost none mentioned checkout or payment friction. Price, product data and reviews came up most.

Finding 3.1

Can Today's Payment and Fraud Checks Block AI Agents From Completing Purchases?

The gap merchants aren't counting
Bases: 161 and 162 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.
34%
run a check they expect would stop an agent at checkout
2%
expect checkout or payment friction to cost them an agent sale
Data for: The gap merchants aren't counting
LabelValueSourceBase
run a check they expect would stop an agent at checkout34%——
expect checkout or payment friction to cost them an agent sale2%——
Listen

“Right now we have completely blocked at this point agents to access the checkout page. If the checkout page is not being accessed by a human, then we simply do not let any agent to proceed to the checkout page.”

Customer experience, service and product, online food delivery marketplace
when asked about payment and fraud checks
Listen

“So today, our fraud and monitoring parameters are not tailored for AI, and we are having lots of false positives whenever AI agents are trying to either gather information or make a purchase. A lot of user accounts are being blocked, and they can't proceed on our site because of this.”

Product and growth, online marketplace
when asked about payment and fraud checks
Finding 3.2

Where Agents Already Buy, Errors Already Show Up

Strategic Implication
Is there anything in how you handle payments or fraud checks that might stop an AI agent completing a purchase?
13%
Bot detection, CAPTCHAs or web firewalls
Bot detection, CAPTCHAs or web firewalls
13%
Fraud rules on velocity, unusual patterns or address mismatches
11%
Multi-factor authentication, 3D Secure or biometrics
9%
No known barrier
40%
Other answers
26%
Percentages may not total 100 because of rounding. Bases include respondents who answered the question.
Data for: Is there anything in how you handle payments or fraud checks that might stop an AI agent completing a purchase?
LabelValueSourceBase
Bot detection, CAPTCHAs or web firewalls13%Base: 161 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Fraud rules on velocity, unusual patterns or address mismatches11%Base: 161 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Multi-factor authentication, 3D Secure or biometrics9%Base: 161 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
No known barrier40%Base: 161 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Other answers26%Base: 161 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—

Percentages may not total 100 because of rounding. Bases include respondents who answered the question.

“They're not sending it to the AI agent, they're sending it to the human. So, that's the only sticking point.”

Founder and CEO, consumer goods brand
when asked about payment and fraud checks

“So most cases when an agent orders a product, the sizing is off, and then there's always a return initiated.”

Marketing, growth, e-commerce and CX, fashion e-commerce company
when asked about payment and fraud checks
Chapter 04

The Online Checkout Survives as a Single Moment of Human Approval

Merchants don't expect agents to kill the checkout. More than half (56%) say it will survive in some form, with a person confirming the purchase and security checks in place, and only 9% expect cart abandonment to fade within two years.

Finding 4.1

What Replaces the Online Checkout When AI Agents Do the Buying?

Could the online checkout be phased out? If so, what replaces it?

56%

It survives, with human confirmation and safeguards

It survives, with human confirmation and safeguards56%
Wallets, platform checkouts or passkeys replace it14%
It becomes a conversational or voice confirmation4%
Agents pay each other in the background4%
Other answers22%

Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.

Base: 167 online sellers

Bases include respondents who answered the question.

Data for: Could the online checkout be phased out? If so, what replaces it?
LabelValueSourceBase
It survives, with human confirmation and safeguards56%G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.167 online sellers
Wallets, platform checkouts or passkeys replace it14%G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.167 online sellers
It becomes a conversational or voice confirmation4%G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.167 online sellers
Agents pay each other in the background4%G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.167 online sellers
Other answers22%G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.167 online sellers

Bases include respondents who answered the question.

“I think the moment of authorization won't disappear though.”

Founder, education publisher
when asked about the future of the online checkout
Listen

“I suspect that there will be a tipping point in the future where it becomes easier to make a purchase using an AI agent than it is to do it as a human being through a traditional e-commerce journey.”

Product director, internet service provider
when asked about the future of the online checkout
Finding 4.2

How Fast Is This Moving?

63%

of online sellers don't let AI agents complete purchases yet

Can AI agents complete purchases on behalf of your customers today?
29%
Yes, live today
Yes, live today
29%
Testing
8%
Not yet
63%
Other answers
1%
Percentages may not total 100 because of rounding. Bases include respondents who answered the question.
Data for: Can AI agents complete purchases on behalf of your customers today?
LabelValueSourceBase
Yes, live today29%All online sellers, base: 166. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Testing8%All online sellers, base: 166. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Not yet63%All online sellers, base: 166. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Other answers1%All online sellers, base: 166. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—

Percentages may not total 100 because of rounding. Bases include respondents who answered the question.

Finding 4.3

Will Metrics Tied to Human Shopping, Such as Cart Abandonment, Stop Mattering?

Strategic Implication
Will metrics tied to human shopping, such as cart abandonment, stop mattering?
54%
No, they stay essential
No, they stay essential
54%
Yes, in 3 to 5 years or more
10%
Yes, within 1 to 2 years
9%
Other answers
27%
Bases include respondents who answered the question.
Data for: Will metrics tied to human shopping, such as cart abandonment, stop mattering?
LabelValueSourceBase
No, they stay essential54%All online sellers, base: 165. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Yes, in 3 to 5 years or more10%All online sellers, base: 165. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Yes, within 1 to 2 years9%All online sellers, base: 165. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Other answers27%All online sellers, base: 165. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—

Bases include respondents who answered the question.

Listen

“I do think human driven shopping metrics will always be important. There will always be a subset of the population that does not feel comfortable using AI for a variety of different reasons and just prefer to do things manually.”

Owner, online reseller
when asked about the future of the online checkout
Chapter 05

Merchants Are Betting on Reputation to Win Over AI Shopping Agents

When price is level, merchants expect brand reputation and reviews to make an agent choose them. Fewer bet on the structured product data agents rely on. Nearly two in three (64%) say it would matter if customers kept buying but stopped seeing their brand.

“Absolutely. I think it's crucial that the brand is visible and has been seen by the customers. Otherwise it becomes replaceable, and it's not an asset anymore.”

— Managing director, fashion retailer

Listen
Finding 5.1

What Makes an AI Agent Pick One Merchant Over Another at Similar Prices?

Strategic Implication
What would make an agent pick your company over a competitor at a similar or lower price?
33%
Reputation, authority and verified reviews
Reputation, authority and verified reviews
33%
Product quality, fit and delivery speed
18%
Structured product data and AI search visibility
13%
Loyalty and post-purchase service
6%
Other answers
30%
Bases include respondents who answered the question.
Data for: What would make an agent pick your company over a competitor at a similar or lower price?
LabelValueSourceBase
Reputation, authority and verified reviews33%Base: 165 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Product quality, fit and delivery speed18%Base: 165 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Structured product data and AI search visibility13%Base: 165 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Loyalty and post-purchase service6%Base: 165 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Other answers30%Base: 165 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—

Bases include respondents who answered the question.

Listen

“It might misunderstand where we're trying to position ourselves as a brand: more higher end. So, I suppose from a pricing point of view, we're not the cheapest, but in terms of the ingredients, we are certainly one of the best.”

Marketing, growth and e-commerce, supplements brand
when asked about brand visibility with AI agents
Listen

“One of the things we would increase significantly would be our loyalty concept. We have a loyalty club for past customers, and that would be a more critical and more important tool for us if the purchasing process is taken over by AI agents, which kind of make our company become invisible and turn the brand into more like a generic product. Then we'll need to look much more intensely into the time between purchasing.”

Marketing, growth and e-commerce, travel company
when asked about brand visibility with AI agents
Chapter 06

No One Owns the Customer Experience Once Several AI Agents Are Involved

When a purchase runs through several AI tools and something goes wrong, merchants don't agree on who should fix it. The most common answer, shared ownership across teams, came from only 20%. And half (51%) expect to hear about the problem first from an unhappy customer.

Finding 6.1

Who Is Accountable When an AI Agent's Purchase Goes Wrong Across Several Platforms?

“I can't imagine the customer would then come on and make a complaint or track it in another way. They'd just come on and either buy it or go somewhere else.”

Marketing, growth and e-commerce, toy retailer
Strategic Implication
If a customer's journey spans several AI tools and goes wrong, who in your business is responsible?
20%
Shared across marketing, product and tech
Shared across marketing, product and tech
20%
E-commerce and digital product teams
17%
Customer service and support
16%
Leadership, operations or payments teams
10%
Other answers, often "it depends"
36%
Percentages may not total 100 because of rounding. Bases include respondents who answered the question.
Data for: If a customer's journey spans several AI tools and goes wrong, who in your business is responsible?
LabelValueSourceBase
Shared across marketing, product and tech20%Base: 167 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
E-commerce and digital product teams17%Base: 167 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Customer service and support16%Base: 167 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Leadership, operations or payments teams10%Base: 167 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—
Other answers, often "it depends"36%Base: 167 online sellers. Source: G2 Research, agentic commerce merchant study, October 2026.—

Percentages may not total 100 because of rounding. Bases include respondents who answered the question.

Listen

“There is shared responsibility in my business. So you have the marketing team, the sales team, the IT team, we have agencies, and of course the board. It would be shared responsibility.”

Marketing, growth and e-commerce, leisure venues operator
when asked about who owns a failed agent journey
Chapter 07

Same Blind Spots Everywhere, but US Merchants Are Calmer About Them

Merchants in all three regions gave similar answers on most questions. Around three in ten already let agents buy, most can't fully tell an agent's order from a human's, and about half expect to hear about agent problems from complaints. Where they differ is how worried they are: US merchants are consistently the calmest, while UK and European merchants are more alert to what agents could change.

Two bar charts of online sellers by region (US / UK / Europe). Where the US, UK and Europe agree: AI agents can already complete purchases 27% / 30% / 29% (bases 81 / 50 / 34); can't fully tell agent orders from human ones 70% / 78% / 75% (73 / 50 / 32); would see nothing if an agent chose a competitor 33% / 37% / 28% (73 / 51 / 32); expect checkout to survive as a human approval step 60% / 58% / 44% (80 / 52 / 34); expect complaints to be the first warning 53% / 46% / 50% (81 / 50 / 34). Where they differ: say their reporting is still trusted 49% / 35% / 24% (79 / 51 / 33); expect little or no change for shoppers who skip agents 55% / 37% / 41% (77 / 52 / 34); have no checkout redesign plans yet 31% / 20% / 12% (80 / 50 / 33); think price or value is why an agent would drop them 16% / 33% / 24% (76 / 51 / 34).
Finding 7.1

How Does Agentic Commerce Readiness Differ Across the US, UK and Europe?

Strategic Implication
What to do

What merchants should do before agents become a large share of sales

01
Critical

Audit the Security Stack for Agents

34% of online sellers run checks they expect would stop an agent, yet only 2% think checkout friction could cost them an agent sale. List every CAPTCHA, fraud rule, one-time code and 3D Secure step a purchase passes through, and decide which should recognize a verified agent acting with the customer's permission and which must always stop and ask a person. Ask your payment provider how it will handle agentic payments and verify that an agent really acts for the customer. Reviewing your fraud protection and payment gateway settings with this question in mind is the quickest place to start.

02
Critical

Learn to Recognize Agent Orders, Then Measure Agent Abandonment

Only 12% of merchants with agent purchases live can reliably tell an agent order from a human one, and a third (34%) would see nothing when an agent walks away. Tag agent traffic wherever your tools allow, then log the agent sessions that fail and where they stop.

03
High

Keep the Confirmation Step and Make It Fast

56% expect checkout to survive as a moment of human approval. Design one clear, secure confirmation, the heart of the agentic checkout, and remove the form-filling around it.

04
High

Write the Brand Story so a Machine Can Read It

Positioning is what merchants most expect agents to misread (24%). State plainly why you cost more, what makes the product different and what the customer gets, and back it with structured product data, which shapes how AI agents read websites. Then test the prompts customers type into AI shopping assistants to see how agents describe you.

05
Moderate

Name One Owner for the Multi-Agent Journey

The most common answer on ownership came from only 20%, and 51% expect a complaint to be their first warning. Give one team the job of monitoring agents acting for you and for your customers, with signals that arrive before the complaint does.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Question 1

What Is Agentic Commerce?

Conclusion

Trust decides who wins the agent-ready checkout

Taken together, the interviews describe merchants who have opened the door to AI agents before switching on the lights. Three in ten say agents can already buy from them. Most can't tell when it happens or see when an agent leaves, and a third run security checks that could turn legitimate agents away without anyone noticing. The fixes sit in the plumbing more than the storefront. Recognizing an agent that acts with a customer's permission, keeping one clear moment of approval and measuring what agents do are payments, identity and data problems. Merchants that solve them first will see agent demand while their competitors still file it under bot traffic.

Sponsored

Research Prepared for Paysafe

About the sponsor

Paysafe is a global payments platform built for the experience economy. We connect businesses, consumers, and fans across iGaming, video gaming, esports, events, travel, hospitality, online trading and digital commerce, helping lift everyday and high-engagement experiences through reliable payment solutions. These include card payments, digital wallets such as Skrill, PaysafeWallet, eCash products like PaysafeCard, and a broad set of local payment methods. With approximately 2,800 employees across 12 countries and $167 billion in annualized volume in 2025, Paysafe focuses on making digital experiences easier to access and pay for. More information is available at www.paysafe.com.

www.paysafe.com

This research was commissioned by Paysafe. G2 maintains full editorial independence.

Paysafe
Methodology

For this agentic commerce report, G2 conducted 206 AI-moderated voice interviews between October 5 and 25, 2026, with e-commerce, digital commerce, customer experience, product and payments leaders at companies in the US, UK and Europe. Three independent research panels recruited respondents, targeting director-level and above leaders in retail and e-commerce, travel and hospitality, gaming and entertainment, and iGaming. Interviews averaged 20 minutes (10 to 45 minutes) and followed a structured guide of 26 questions on agentic purchasing and the future of online checkout. All 197 respondents with panel screener records were at director level or above (head of function, director, VP, C-suite or founder), and half (49%) are C-suite executives, founders or VPs. Among the 169 online sellers, 52 work at companies with more than 1,000 employees and 16 at companies with more than 10,000.

Statistics in this report use the 169 respondents whose companies sell to customers online. We set aside 37 respondents whose companies aren't online merchants: businesses that sell through consulting, invoicing or in person, technology and payment providers, consultants describing a client's business, and brands that sell only through retailers or distributors. Each chart states its base, which excludes people who didn't answer that question.

G2 Interviews grouped open answers into categories with AI-assisted analysis, and G2's research team reviewed the coding and every quote against the transcripts. Quotes are lightly edited for readability: we removed filler words such as "um" and "uh", false starts and repeated words, added punctuation and corrected obvious transcription errors, without changing what respondents said. They are attributed by role, industry and company size. Just over half of the 169 (54%) work at companies with up to 250 employees, answers are self-reported, and no figure in this report rests on fewer than 30 respondents.

Regional comparisons are based on panel screener records of each respondent's country: US 82, UK 52 and Europe 34 (Germany 17, Denmark 5, Netherlands 3, Sweden 3, Norway 2, Italy 1, Finland 1, Switzerland 1 and Ireland 1).

This article was originally published in November 2026 and updated in November 2026.

About This Research
206AI-moderated voice interviews
169online sellers (base for every statistic)
20 minaverage interview length
3regions: US, UK and Europe
Respondent Roles
Marketing, growth and e-commerce61%Customer experience, service and product15%Payments and operations6%Other or several areas18%
Industries
Retail, fashion and consumer goods64%Travel, hospitality and dining11%Gaming, entertainment and digital media7%B2B, technology and marketplace platforms4%Other industries14%
Company size: Up to 250 employees 54%, 251 to 1,000 13%, 1,001 to 10,000 21%, More than 10,000 9%, Not stated clearly 2%. Bases: 169, 168 and 167 online sellers. Categories come from what respondents said in the interview. Percentages may not total 100 because of rounding.

G2 is the world's largest and most trusted software marketplace.

Commission Research

Make Your Category the Next G2 Report.

Partner with G2 Research on an original study built from real buyer interviews and structured for AI citation.

Commission a Study